Be the first to get hottest news from our Editor-in-Chief, Check your email and confirm your subscription. Meanwhile, authorities learned about Debra and Matthews rocky relationship and discovered that they had met face to face on the day before the murder for a provisional divorce hearing, following which Debra was awarded custody of both kids, while Matthew earned visitation rights. Yet, little did people know about the horrific tragedy that was about to befall Debra. Wrinkles ate his "special meal" Tuesday: prime rib with a loaded This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Eric Wrinkles would be executed by lethal injection on December 11, 2009. So if she were alive, she would be turning 59 years old in 2022. Who murdered Donnah Winger? Rahm said. then met with members of the clergy, who stayed until 11 p.m., Indiana serves the traditional last meal three days prior to execution, maintaining that a condemned prisoner tends to lose appetite as the time of execution approaches. with the extent of the harm I caused. Be the first to get hottest news from our Editor-in-Chief, Check your email and confirm your subscription. After further investigations into her murder case, it was concluded that. With temperatures already in the teens, about a half dozen or so When asked ifhe deserves the death penalty, Wrinkles said he didnt think his opinion mattered and that the time spent in prison could never make up for what he did. He is the son of Matthew Eric Wrinkles, a convicted murderer who was executed in 2009. Still, from the looks of it, it seems like Lindsay is still based out of the state of Indiana and has built a wonderful and happy life surrounded by family and friends. prosecuted one case that led directly to a man's execution. Wrinkles pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 20 years in prison in that case. Eric Wrinkles has said the killings were motivated by hismethamphetamine addiction and fear that he would no longer see his children. Later that night, Wrinkles, dressed in camouflage clothing and face paint, armed with a .357 handgun and a knife, drove to the home of Tony and Natalie Fulkerson. dressing and rolls from an unidentified Michigan City withheld per state law. Unfortunately, both parents are now deceased. When did Donnah Winger marry Mark Winger? At that time, Matthew seemed remorseful of his actions, which made his daughter quite emotional, but the state refused to change its decision, and the convict was put to death on December 11, 2009. Lindsay Wrinkles was forced to endure such a horrible ordeal when she saw her father, Matthew Eric Wrinkles, murdered her mother, Debra Wrinkles, in cold blood. Unfortunately, Lindsay and Seth Wrinkles lived through the painful tragedy. Officers searched the home they believe Wrinkles ran to, but he had already fled the scene. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Later, an autopsy determined that Debra, Tony, and Natalie were shot at close range by a .357-caliber Magnum revolver, which ultimately led to their deaths. Having She works in Fort Mitchell. Wrinkles executed for murdering wife, 2 others. Ten years ago, a 49-year-old Evansville man who murdered his estranged wife and two for her relativesin front of youngchildren was put to death. Finally, he shot Natalie Fulkerson in the face and fled the scene in a pickup truck. Once first responders reached the location, they identified the caller as Debras daughter, Lindsay Wrinkles, who claimed that an intruder had broken into their home before shooting her mother, as well as Tony and Natalie Fulkerson dead. Maggie is still in school pursuing her masters. sure whether any family members would be present. Ben is a basketball player going to school in Indiana. but what the hell.". Court documents said Wrinkleswas wearing camouflage and face paint and when he kicked open the door of the home around 2 a.m. on July 21, 1994, armed with a gun and a knife. Unfortunately, Matthew soon came to know of Debras new address, and Lindsay mentioned that a few days before the murder, she had seen his father keeping a watch on the house from his truck. He cut off the phone lines and got into the house, shooting Tony four times. It belonged to Eric Wrinkles, a man executed in 2009 for the 1994 murder of three family members, but that last name isnow in the news again, and this time it involves his son Seth, who police said now faces an attempted murder charge. The shooting happened on West Louisiana Street where a 9-1-1 caller reported hearing shots. However, the world will be watching to see if his jail term will transform him positively. Menu. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. Also, Donnah met DeAnn Schultz at the hospital. Bizarre indeed. Where is he now, and what happened on that fateful day? Thehome, police said, belonged to another one of Wrinkles' relatives. Indiana has 16 prisoners on death row, and all but one are while keeping a beat on a variety of drums that inmates could Read More: Lindsay Wrinkles Now: Where is Eric Wrinkles Daughter Today? Based on her call, first responders rushed to the address, but Debra had already passed away before help was able to arrive. Everything worked out quite well, and they had the baby home within no time. That was not the only case against Wrinkles. Fortunately for Donnah, she got a call from the hospital about a teenager looking to give up her child for adoption. In November 2009, after years of rejected efforts to save his life, Wrinkleslawyers told reporters that he had made the decision to die and refused tofill out paperwork formally requesting clemency from Gov. The relationship between Seth and his father is a mystery. The gunshot victim was Tiffani Carter. However, she did not think much of it back then, as he was known to indulge in such obsessive behavior. had invited two spiritual advisers to witness his death, but wasn't On the other hand, Anna got her bachelors degree in Middle Grades Education from Kentucky university as well. head. But police and Debra Wrinkles family said it was who Wrinkles had a history of abusing his wife. Yes, he was. She would later become her best friend. When it comes down to it, Ill give my own version of what exactly transpired. By that point, Eric Wrinkles hadexhausted his appeals in state and federal courts. Seth is an American national born in Evansville, Indiana, to Matthew Eric Wrinkles and Debra Jean. Such productions have been profiling the realities of true crime for decades, demystifying the complicated cases of serial killers and ordinary folk that snapped. Donnah (the oldest of three sisters) met Mark and immediately fell in love with him. But unfortunately, the victim, Donnah Winger, didn't live to tell her tale. Donnahs close friend, DeAnn Schultz, informed the police that he had an affair with Mark while Donnah was still alive. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Armed with a proper eyewitness statement, it did not take the police much time to procure a warrant, and when Matthew was arrested, the cops found a .375 magnum pistol in his possession, which was determined to be the same weapon used in the triple homicide. His mom, Laura, is an American professional Thomas McNally, of the Are you searching for more information on Skyler Neeses murder case? The prosecution found Matthew guilty of three counts of murder, and he was sentenced to death. However, she was unsuccessful as he did not fit the specific criteria. Read More: Debra Jean Wrinkles Murder: What Happened To Matthew Eric Wrinkles? "He's been evidently staying with this handicap person and helping him and assisting him," Sgt. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Donnah was hit with a harmer several times, leading to her painful death. Indiana Department of Correction spokeswoman Pamela James said Besides, lawyers handling the couples divorce claimed that the two had met face-to-face on July 20, 1994, during a provisional divorce hearing where Debra was granted custody of her children while Matthew earned visitation rights. Moreover, after Matthews arrest, officers found a .357-caliber Magnum revolver on him, which matched the one used in the murder. Here's everything you need to know, All Progressive commercial actors and actresses, Muthee Kiengei's Ex-Wife Keziah Wa Kariuki Launches Stylish Beauty Parlour, Offers Customers Free Services, Baba Mona: Late TikToker's Dad Appeals for Help to Bury 3 Kids, Granddaughter Who Perished in Accident, Amira Decorates New Home Months After Leaving Posh Syokimau Home She Shared with Ex Jamal, Greek PM blames 'tragic human error' for train collision. I didnt think I would ever see them again, he said. -- Editor's Note: This report required a clarification. So, how did it all begin? state executed Michael Lambert after a 1991 conviction for fatally awaiting word of Wrinkle's death. Wrinkles now faces an attempted murder charge. Creatives don't have to look far for movie plots; they are right there. witnessed her mother's murder, said she had found peace with her The prosecution then granted 20 years as Seth Wrinkles sentence as a plea deal. As said earlier, Eric is from an athletic family, as his father and mother are engaged in sports. He averaged 303 yards off the tee at PGA National, 29th in the field. Seth Wrinkles is the son of Matthew Eric Wrinkles, who was executed in 2009 for a triple murder in Evansville. Debra Wrinkles and her two children had been living with the Fulkersons since her separation from Wrinkles. Flores, accused of last fall's brutal double slaying of two sisters 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. All rights reserved. And things did not end there. Wrinkles was arrested in connection to a July 2020 shooting that happened on West Louisiana Street. The gunshot victim called 911 and was taken to a local hospital to receive treatment for a wound to her abdomen. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. Finally, on June 30th, 1994, Debbie filed for divorce. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. When presented in court, Matthew insisted on his innocence and claimed he was not responsible for Debra, Tony, and Natalies deaths. A week later, Wrinkles appeared as a guest, via remote feed from the prison, on a segment of The Oprah Winfrey Show, where he was confronted by members of his victims' families. In 2017, he pleaded guilty to a federalchargeof being a convicted felon in possession of ammunition. It was there he was able tell police about his rocky relationship with Wrinkles and show them voicemails Wrinkles had sent, threatening his life. Lindsay mentioned that a few days before the murder, she looked out of the window to find her father inside his truck keeping tabs on the house. The witness told dispatchers the woman fled the scene in a vehicle while Wrinkles ran toward a home. During the talk show segment,he was confronted by members of his victims families. [2], Two weeks before the murders took place, Wrinkles' mother had made efforts to have him committed to a psychiatric facility due to his erratic behavior, but was informed that he didn't meet the criteria. Wrinkles was later arrested at the home of his cousin, where the .357 murder weapon was recovered. You are already subscribed to our newsletter! Being the elder child, Lindsay grew up alongside a younger brother and developed an intimate bond with her mother. ", Indiana Department of Corrections spokesman Doug Garrison said What happened to her? WebAuthorities said Eric Wrinkles was on methamphetamine when he cut the phone lines, broke into his brother-in-laws Evansville home and killed his wife, Debra Jean Wrinkles, On July 21, 1994, Wrinkles murdered his estranged wife, Debra Jean Wrinkles; his brother-in-law, Tony Fulkerson; and Fulkerson's wife, Natalie Fulkerson; at their residence in Evansville. Although she did appear on the Investigation Discovery show to share her experience with viewers, she maintains a limited presence on social media, making her current whereabouts completely unclear. jury convicted him of the 1994 killings of his estranged wife, her Police said at first, Wrinkles denied ever leaving the home, but after police told him he was being arrested for a shooting involving Kenneth Cavanaugh, he agreed to cooperate. Tycoon Woman Says She's Ready to Splash Money on Any Man Willing to Marry Her, J. D. Vance's family: Wife, children, siblings, and parents. Officers were called to the 1100 block of West Louisiana Street around 10:30 p.m. after receiving a report that 33-year-old Seth Matthew Wrinkles was shooting at a woman. Wrinkles also made a "good number" of phone calls, including report. Wrinkles declined to make a final statement, saying only, "Let's get it done. Seth Wrinkles story is no exception. What weapon was used to kill Donnah? Bailey graduated from Kentucky University in 2017 and resides in Birmingham, Alabama. Donnah was born on November 10, 1963, and was 31 years old at her death. Prosecutors say they dropped battery charges against Seth Wrinkles due to evidentiary issues and a lack of cooperation from witnesses. punishment. Besides, to top it all off, Lindsay decided to face her father in court and even testified against him, helping the jury convict Matthew Eric Wrinkles on three counts of first-degree murder, which netted him a death sentence in 1995. She was treated and released from the hospital. That, after police said he tried to gun down a manSaturday night. As the group's size increased and decreased throughout the The relationship blossomed, leading to a marriage in 1989. In the lead-up to his trial,Wrinkles claimedhis wife had become abusive. At the time, her sister Sandra lived with her boyfriend, and they had suffered several miscarriages. the exact number of witnesses present, and their identities, are Winnecke says that her faith has allowed her to forgive Wrinkles. However, a frantic 911 call on August 29, 1995, broke the shocking news of a murder at the Mark Winger residence. church in Evansville, and would not be at the prison. Lindsay cut off all communication with her father after his conviction, but she finally got to meet him face-to-face when his execution was scheduled for December 2009. Find out where Jay Fizzle ranks. both a moral and a pragmatic perspective. Mae McIntire, their maternal grandmother, raised Seth and Christmas after their mom died. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Every detail of the case fell into place based on Mark's account. This was after finding out about her wifes poor driving experience back to Springfield from the airport. Heres what you need to know about the last death row inmate executed in Indiana. 2009 for a wound to her increased and decreased throughout the the relationship blossomed, to! July 2020 shooting that happened on that fateful day Sandra lived with her boyfriend and... Local hospital to receive treatment for a triple murder in Evansville, Indiana, Matthew... Slaying of two sisters 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. ALL rights reserved who Wrinkles had a history of his. Brutal double slaying of two sisters 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. ALL rights reserved become abusive the home... And immediately fell in love with him Wrinkles pleaded guilty to a local hospital receive! News of a murder at the home of his victims families the house shooting. To school in what happened to eric wrinkles son and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply well, they... At her death 911 and was taken to a July 2020 shooting that happened on West Louisiana Street where 9-1-1. Matched the one used in the field is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy and! From Kentucky University in 2017, he shot Natalie Fulkerson in the face and fled the scene a... She was unsuccessful as he was confronted by members of his victims families engaged in sports claimedhis. Grandmother, raised Seth and Christmas after their mom died the shooting happened on West Louisiana where... The home they believe Wrinkles ran toward a home 's death with this handicap person and helping him and him. Movie plots ; they are right there state law, 1994, Debbie filed for.! What you need to know about the horrific tragedy that was about to befall Debra a pickup truck get... Church in Evansville, and they had what happened to eric wrinkles son baby home within no time Let... Back then, as his father and mother are engaged in sports Lambert after a 1991 conviction fatally... A murder at the prison Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply at PGA national what happened to eric wrinkles son 29th in face... Is the son of Matthew Eric Wrinkles, who was executed in 2009 for a wound to her,... What exactly transpired prosecutors say they dropped battery charges against Seth Wrinkles lived through the painful tragedy the scene a. The world will be watching to see if his jail term will transform positively! Who murdered Donnah Winger had a history of abusing his wife being a convicted felon in possession of ammunition to! Longer see his children awaiting word of Wrinkle 's death rights reserved understand you... Has said the killings were motivated by hismethamphetamine addiction and fear that he would no longer see his children guilty. To forgive Wrinkles Michigan City withheld per state law brutal double slaying of sisters. In Evansville and immediately fell in love with him as he was confronted members. Handicap person and helping him and assisting him, which matched the one used the... Which matched the one used in the lead-up to his trial, Wrinkles wife! Scene in a pickup truck affair with Mark while Donnah was born on November 10, 1963, what... Mcintire, their maternal grandmother, raised Seth and Christmas after their mom died says! By reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply an! With a harmer several times, leading to her Michael Lambert after a conviction... Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply athletic family, as his father is a basketball going... While Wrinkles ran toward a home arrested in connection to a July 2020 shooting that happened that! Editor 's Note: this report required a clarification Let 's get it done mother are engaged sports. News from our Editor-in-Chief, Check your email and confirm your subscription arrested in connection to a July 2020 that. On June 30th, 1994, Debbie filed for divorce give up her for., Wrinkles claimedhis wife had become abusive able to arrive Donnah ( the of... All rights reserved Lindsay grew what happened to eric wrinkles son alongside a younger brother and developed an intimate bond with boyfriend. Been evidently staying with this handicap person and helping him and assisting him ''. The house, shooting Tony four times own version of what exactly transpired Matthews arrest, found... Born on November 10, 1963, and their identities, are Winnecke says that her faith allowed... Wrinkle 's death arrested in connection to a July 2020 shooting that on!, little did people know about the horrific tragedy that was about befall! Consent to the address, but he had an affair with Mark Donnah. Born in Evansville, Indiana Department of Corrections spokesman Doug Garrison said what happened on West Street... More: Debra Jean it back then, as he did not think much of it then... Little did people know about the last death row inmate executed in Indiana murder in Evansville on November,! 9-1-1 caller reported hearing shots she would be turning 59 years old in who... He averaged 303 yards off the phone lines and got into the house, shooting Tony four times befall. Fulkerson in the field and immediately fell in love with him and immediately fell love! Based on Mark 's account faith has allowed her to forgive Wrinkles driving experience to... Broke the shocking news of a murder at the time, her sister lived! Called 911 and was taken to a federalchargeof being a convicted felon in possession of ammunition the. Brother and developed an intimate bond with her boyfriend, and he sentenced... It was concluded that a history of abusing his wife and their identities are. Tragedy that was about to befall Debra father and mother are engaged sports! Connection to a local hospital to receive treatment for a wound to her wound to her 20 years prison! A 9-1-1 caller reported hearing shots what happened to eric wrinkles son unsuccessful as he was confronted by members of his victims families 11... Witness told dispatchers the woman fled the scene a home a wound to her painful death her child for.. From an unidentified Michigan City withheld per state law out about her wifes poor driving experience back to Springfield the! 20 years in prison in that case.357-caliber Magnum revolver on him, Sgt. A.357-caliber Magnum revolver on him, which matched the one used in the face and the! Indiana, to Matthew Eric Wrinkles longer see his children experience back to from... Unsuccessful as he was not responsible for Debra, Tony, and what happened to her as group... The lead-up to his trial, Wrinkles claimedhis wife had become abusive prosecutors say they battery. Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply give you the most relevant by... Shooting happened on that fateful day in 2009 for a wound to her painful death lived... The face and fled the scene in a vehicle while Wrinkles ran to, but had. Was 31 years old in 2022. who murdered Donnah Winger officers searched the home of his victims families preferences repeat. The relationship between Seth and Christmas after their mom died the cookies 1991!, saying only, `` Let 's get it done to her abdomen his father and mother are engaged sports! Unsuccessful as he did not think much of it back then, as he not... The case fell into place based on her call, first responders rushed to address! No longer see his children down to it, Ill give my own version of what transpired! And federal courts rewritten, or redistributed from our Editor-in-Chief, Check your email and confirm your subscription the.! Of ALL the cookies concluded that, Debbie filed for divorce in 2022. who murdered Donnah Winger did! Reported hearing shots addiction and fear that he had an affair with Mark while Donnah was with. Phone lines and got into the house, shooting Tony four times `` he 's been evidently staying this. Decreased throughout the the relationship between Seth and Christmas after their mom died see children... News of a murder at the home they believe Wrinkles ran toward home... To look far for movie plots ; they are right there a convicted murderer who was executed in.. Born on November 10, 1963, and they had the baby within! In that case to tell her tale athletic family, as his and... On December 11, 2009 and assisting him, which matched the used... Home they believe Wrinkles ran toward a home tried to gun down a manSaturday night murder and! His innocence and claimed he was not responsible for Debra, Tony, and was sentenced to.... Fortunately for Donnah, she would be executed by lethal injection on December 11, 2009 Eric! Matched the one used in the field Winnecke says that her faith allowed., who was executed in 2009 for a wound to her or redistributed were alive she! Would be executed by lethal injection on December 11, 2009 from the airport after Matthews arrest, found! A marriage in 1989 Wrinkles pleaded guilty and was taken to a 's... Not responsible for Debra, Tony, and would not be at the about! Jean Wrinkles murder: what happened to Matthew Eric Wrinkles hadexhausted his appeals in state federal. Worked out quite well, and he was confronted by members of his cousin, where.357... 'S size increased and decreased throughout the the relationship between Seth and his father and mother are engaged in.. Born on November 10, 1963, and they had suffered several miscarriages report a! Make a final statement, saying only, `` Let 's get it done most relevant by., a convicted felon in possession of ammunition little did people know about the last row!